| 2023 |
- Elle Burnette, Golf — UNC-Greensboro
- Simeon Jeffers, Basketball — University of Toronto
- Vytas Nausedas, Basketball — University of Guelph
- Saransh Padhy, Basketball — McGill University
- Markus Pastorcic-Straun, Basketball — Colorado School of Mines
|
| 2022 |
- Imran Armstrong, Basketball — Western University, Ontario, CAN
- Cole Donner, Lacrosse — Wingate University
- Jack McErlean, Basketball — Georgia Southwestern University
- Tate Sheally, Soccer — University of Denver
- Ben Smith, Sailing — Georgetown University
- George Wall, Soccer — Guilford College
|
| 2021 |
- Devon Cavanaugh, Lacrosse — University of Pittsburgh
- Matthew Ezzell, Lacrosse — Washington and Lee University
- Gavin Guion, Basketball — Georgia Southwestern University
- Evan Marinov, Basketball — Luther College
- Liza Murtagh, Swimming — Boston College
|
| 2020 |
- Emmanuel Bonsu, Basketball — Stonehill College
- Caroline Crumrine, Golf — Furman University
- Chloe Kernan, Basketball — Washington University, St. Louis
- Lacey Kleppinger, Tennis — Belmont Abbey College
- Lilly Lancaster, Field Hockey — Wake Forest University
- Georges Lefebvre, Basketball — University of Vermont
- Ivan Misic, Basketball — Bentley University
- Kaia Simpson, Basketball — University of Mount Olive
- Connor Smith, Soccer — Davidson College
|
| 2019 |
- Matt Kiatipis, Basketball — Simon Fraser University
- Preston Meehl, Lacrosse — Rhodes College
- Ethan Miles, Soccer — Virginia Military Institute
- Libby Moore, Soccer — UNC Chapel Hill
- Henry Murtagh, Lacrosse — Stevens Institute of Technology
- Holt Robinson, Soccer — Colgate University
- Ana Sharbaugh, Rowing — University of Notre Dame
- Kyndall Shaw, Football Cheerleading Squad — Furman University
|
| 2018 |
- Cole Boggio, Lacrosse — Roanoke College
- Chase Carraway, Sailing — Hobart and William Smith Colleges
- Delaney Mitchell, Soccer — Towson University
- Grant Reed, Basketball — Trinity University, TX
|
| 2017 |
- Lauren Birmingham, Swimming — Bryn Mawr College
- Will Coverdale, Basketball — Volunteer State Community College
- Lexi Lampkin, Football Cheerleading Squad — Washington University, St. Louis
|
| 2016 |
- Tony Batchler, Lacrosse — Guilford College
|
| 2015 |
- Trey Carraway, Sailing — Jacksonville University
- Trey Moore, Soccer — Washington and Lee University
|
| 2014 |
- Brooke Graham, Tennis — Wofford College
- Rebecca McLean, Field Hockey — Appalachian State University
- Ross Robison, Golf — UNC-Wilmington
|
| 2013 |
- AJ Aziz, Tennis — Boston College
- Taylor James, Lacrosse — Meredith College
- Pat Regan, Lacrosse — St. Mary’s College, MD
- Eliza Schuett, Sailing — University of Virginia
|
| 2012 |
- Taylor Brennan, Tennis — Meredith College
- Chelsea Rosenberg, Football Cheerleading Squad — Stanford University
- Begga Tomasdottir, Basketball — Tompkins Courtland Community College
- Michele Whipple, Basketball — Greensboro College
|
| 2011 |
- Cole Howard, Lacrosse — Berry College
- Brittain Knowles, Football and Basketball Cheerleading Squad — NC State University
- Dorrie Mercer, Basketball — Hood College
- Alec Randall, Crew — Georgetown University
- Carley Shafer, Basketball — Valley Forge Military College
|
| 2009 |
- Anna Barry, Lacrosse — Birmingham Southern College
- Mary Biehner, Soccer -—Lees-McRae College
- TK Kairys, Basketball — St. Francis College/Eastern Wyoming College
|
| 2008 |
- Raphaela Jochimczyk, Basketball — Fairmont State University
- Elise Rouse, Tennis — Salem College
- Jessica Stitt, Soccer — Eckerd College
- Jackson Taylor, Golf — Davidson College
|
| 2007 |
- Jason Aycock, Basketball — UNC Wilmington
- Dylan Hubbard, Fencing — UNC Chapel Hill
- Cori Niemann, Lacrosse — Sewanee: The University of the South
- Brian Wiese, Basketball — Hope College
|
| 2006 |
- Khale Gay, Basketball and Lacrosse — Endicott College
|
| 2005 |
- Sami Badawi, Basketball — Newberry College/University of New Orleans
- Miguel Rodriguez, Swimming — Davidson College
|
| 2004 |
- Liz Cherry, Field Hockey — Providence College
|
| 2003 |
- Sprague Paynter, Basketball — Emory University
|
| 2000 |
- Hannah Neal, Volleyball and Basketball — UNC Asheville
|
